User Testing

The information presented within this glossary entry is aimed at website owners seeking to learn the ropes of web accessibility. Technical elements are described in layman’s terms, and, as a rule, all topics pertaining to the legalities of web accessibility are presented in as simplified a manner as possible. This guide has no legal bearing, and cannot be relied on in the case of litigation.

User testing, often referred to as usability testing, is a methodological approach where real users interact with a product, service, or website under controlled conditions. The primary objective is to identify potential usability issues, areas of confusion, and other barriers that might hinder a smooth user experience.

In the realm of web accessibility, user testing takes on added significance. It ensures that websites and digital platforms are not only functional but also accessible and usable by individuals with various disabilities. By involving participants from diverse backgrounds, including those with vision, hearing, motor, or cognitive impairments, user testing provides invaluable insights into how different users navigate and experience a website.

The importance of user testing in web accessibility cannot be overstated. Automated tools can detect technical accessibility issues, but human users can provide feedback on subjective experiences, such as ease of navigation, clarity of content, and overall satisfaction. This feedback is crucial for designers and developers to make informed decisions and prioritize changes that will have the most significant impact on user experience.

Moreover, as the digital landscape continues to evolve, user expectations also change. Regular user testing ensures that websites remain updated with current accessibility standards and user preferences, fostering an inclusive digital environment for all.

User testing techniques and tools

User testing includes a variety of techniques and tools, each designed to gather specific types of feedback and insights from users. When focusing on web accessibility, these methods are tailored to ensure that digital platforms can be fully-accessed, operated, and enjoyed by users with diverse abilities and needs. Some of the most common tools and approaches include:

  • Think-aloud protocol: This technique involves users verbalizing their thoughts, feelings, and decisions as they navigate through a website. It offers real-time insights into user behavior and helps identify areas of confusion or difficulty. For accessibility testing, it can reveal challenges faced by users with disabilities
  • Remote user testing: Leveraging online tools, testers from different locations can evaluate a website. This method is especially valuable for gathering feedback from users with disabilities who might find it challenging to participate in on-site tests
  • Screen recording: Tools that record user sessions capture how users interact with a website, highlighting areas where they may struggle. When combined with voice recordings, it provides a comprehensive view of the user's experience
  • Assistive technology testing: This involves testing websites using assistive tools and technologies that people with disabilities commonly use, such as screen readers, voice recognition software, and braille displays. It ensures that the site is compatible and usable with these technologies
  • A/B testing: By presenting users with two different versions of a webpage or feature, designers can determine which one offers a better user experience. For accessibility, this can help choose between different design or navigation options
  • Surveys and questionnaires: After user testing sessions, participants can provide feedback through structured surveys. This method gathers quantitative data on user satisfaction, areas of difficulty, and suggestions for improvement

User testing's role in complying with web accessibility legislation

Web accessibility legislation aims to ensure that digital platforms, including websites and applications, are accessible to all users, including those with disabilities. Central to many of these legislations globally is the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), a set of guidelines developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C). WCAG provides a detailed framework for creating accessible online content, and its principles and success criteria have become the benchmark for digital accessibility.

Specific laws, such as Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act in the U.S. and the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) in Canada, have adopted WCAG as their standard for compliance. This means that to be compliant with these laws, digital content must meet the criteria set out in WCAG.

Furthermore, in the U.S., many courts have extended the scope of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to include online domains. While the ADA doesn't explicitly reference WCAG, the Department of Justice and various court rulings have indicated that conforming to WCAG is a reliable means of achieving ADA compliance for online content.

User testing is a crucial component in the web accessibility validation process. It offers direct insights from users, especially those with disabilities, about their experience with a website or application.

While automated tools can detect code-level issues and expert evaluations can address complex accessibility challenges, user testing identifies practical barriers that might be overlooked. Together, these methods ensure that websites not only meet WCAG technical criteria but also provide a genuinely accessible user experience, fulfilling the intent of web accessibility legislation.

Broader usability insights that can be gleaned from user testing

User testing for web accessibility doesn't only identify barriers for individuals with disabilities; it also sheds light on broader usability issues that can affect all users. By observing real users as they navigate a website or application, developers and designers can gain insights into areas of friction, confusion, or inefficiency. This feedback can lead to improvements in site structure, content clarity, and overall user experience. As a result, the benefits of user testing extend beyond accessibility compliance, enhancing the platform's usability and user satisfaction for a diverse audience.

User testing, often referred to as usability testing, is a methodological approach where real users interact with a product, service, or website under controlled conditions. The primary objective is to identify potential usability issues, areas of confusion, and other barriers that might hinder a smooth user experience.

In the realm of web accessibility, user testing takes on added significance. It ensures that websites and digital platforms are not only functional but also accessible and usable by individuals with various disabilities. By involving participants from diverse backgrounds, including those with vision, auditory, motor, or cognitive impairments, user testing provides invaluable insights into how different users navigate and experience a website.

The importance of user testing in web accessibility cannot be overstated. Automated tools can detect technical accessibility issues, but human users can provide feedback on subjective experiences, such as ease of navigation, clarity of content, and overall satisfaction. This feedback is crucial for designers and developers to make informed decisions and prioritize changes that will have the most significant impact on user experience.

Moreover, as the digital landscape continues to evolve, user expectations also change. Regular user testing ensures that websites remain updated with current accessibility standards and user preferences, fostering an inclusive digital environment for all.

#1Automated Web Accessibility Solution for ADA & WCAG Compliance

Drive inclusivity and meet ADA/WCAG guidelines, Try accessWidget for Free!